“I Have Found Justice”-Former Legon VC writes on winning defamation case against successor

Date:

 

Four years ago, I wanted to sue my successor as Vice Chancellor of the University of Ghana for peddling falsehoods about me. When I finally took the decision to sue him a year later, I did not discuss it with anyone because I knew many people would be trying to discourage me from “embarrassing the University of Ghana”. Indeed, the first lawyer I approached about the falsehoods emanating from the Vice Chancellor’s office at the University suggested that it would not be in my interest to be perceived as having turned against the University that I had been so closely associated with for such a long time. Of course, I did not want that.

Unfortunately, as the falsehoods continued over several months and became more intense,I had no choice but to try to stop it. At that time, I used to wonder why there was not a single person at the University who could step in and stop the obvious persecution. I found a couple of people who had tried to speak for me at Academic Board meetings and had been quickly labeled as “Aryeetey’s Boys” or “Aryeetey’s Girls”. Their punishment was to be harassed needlessly by the University management. Some of them became very sick andthat was enough warning to other people who were thinking of supporting my cause. Yes, a whole university and all its other stakeholders lost their voices. No one was interested in discussing openly the new developments with the Africa Integras project. For many, it was simply a feud between two professors. But it was not. It was about integrity; the University’s and mine!

I went to court for two reasons: (1) I needed to prove to the world that I was no criminal and that I had not acted in the way the new University management, led by my successor, was trying to portray me. (2) I wanted to force an independent assessment of the processes that we went through to develop the three Concession Agreements that I signed for this project.

The more I listened to people at the University and in government discuss the project and related processes, the more it became obvious that they had not bothered to understand the project and were not interested in understanding it. They were more interested in finding someone to blame for the mess the University was getting itself into daily by refusing to negotiate reasonably with the project developers. As the University’s situation got worse, the greater the attacks on Ernest Aryeetey became.

The source material for the attacks was the report of a ‘witch-hunt committee’ that my successor put together to review the project in March 2017. The only apparent qualification to be on the committee was a grievance against the former VC. A reading of the report reflected an extremely poor appreciation of corporate finance, law and university management. Yet it became the weapon used by my successor. He used it very effectively to convince the University Council, the university community, the government and other stakeholders about my supposed guilt. They were told about what was in the report and did not assess it against any other relevant facts. The report failed to consult easily available material on the project and presented pre-determined conclusions to make a case for termination of the agreement. It was a very unintellectual document, characterized by a strong hatred for Ernest Aryeetey. Considering the composition of the committee, it was not difficult to fathom why. All the falsehood that was peddled about the project and about me was inspired by that report. The Committee simply gave the Vice Chancellor what he was looking for; a reason to terminate the project and embarrass Ernest Aryeetey.

When I attended the burial service of a departed Legon staff member and I heard what the Reverend Minister said during his homily, I knew it was time for me to act. He said in Fante “This man lying in front of us worked at the University of Ghana for many years and we never heard that he had stolen a pesewa from the University. These days, it is those who have free cars, free accommodation, free electricity, free water, free telephones, etc, who steal millions of dollars. It is not only politicians who are corrupt; academics can be even more corrupt”. This was in the week that a fringe newspaper had accused me directly of complicity in a corrupt $64 million deal, quoting extensively from the ‘witch-hunt committee’ report. The Minister had just seen me walk into the church late. I could not believe that I had become the subject of a homily at a burial service!!!

The last straw that sent me to court was when I heard of what my successor had said about me at a meeting of Convocation on 2nd July 2019. He was trying to make them believe that I was the worst Vice Chancellor Legon had ever had. I was the source of all of Legon’s problems. This was after the University had reported me to EOCO with a complaint of “fraudulent collusion” and I had been forced into a self-cognizance bail of US$15 million. As I sat in the windowless interrogation room at EOCO, it dawned on me that I was not only being deliberately embarrassed; my freedom was being curtailed and my successor wanted to see me in jail for no good reason.

I was very lucky to find a lawyer who believed my story and saw the persecution I was suffering. We offered my successor several opportunities to recant his false statements, but he ignored us completely. We, therefore, developed a clear strategy to prove that his utterances on several platforms were defamatory. That was easy as the internet was awash with these statements. It was so overwhelming that he could not have denied them. We had to show that the statements that he made were false, and that was not difficult either as I had copies of most relevant documents to show the falsehood. I managed to find a star witness who corroborated the evidence authoritatively and credibly. There was more than enough evidence from a three-year period of negotiation and project development to establish that this was never a one-man show and that we followed due process. Unfortunately for my successor, his witness statement was not supported by the documents that he tendered in evidence. Indeed, his documents rather became a great help to my case.

We also had to show that my esteem had been lowered in the eyes of right-thinking members of society, and the judge agreed that my standing had been affected. I did not even bring up my experience at the burial service.

After the hearings had been concluded and I read my “Plaintiff’s Written Address” crafted by my lawyer, I became very optimistic about the likely outcome. It was perfectly written and the logic of the arguments appeared solid to me. I will recommend the address to any lawyer involved in a defamation case.

In the end, the judge agreed with everything that we said and proved in court. He granted all the reliefs I had asked for and compelled Professor Ebenezer Oduro Owusu to issue a written retraction of the defamatory statements and render an unqualified apology to me. He should address this to the members of the University’s staff, the Convocation and the University’s alumni. This should also be published on the University’s Radio Univers on three consecutive occasions within 21 days from the date of the judgement. He also issued an order restraining Professor Ebenezer Oduro Owusu from further defaming me or uttering defamatory statements about me.

As I sat in court listening to the judge read his judgment, I struggled hard not to show any emotion. I guess, in the end, the overwhelming evidence had spoken for itself. The judgment gave me a chance to prove to my grandchildren that their grandfather was no reckless manager and corrupt criminal.

I thank God for ensuring that the truth prevailed in the end. I appreciate the great work that my lawyer, Kwesi Fynn, and his team did. They were very professional and thorough always. I tried very hard not to be a “too-known’ client and I believe it worked out well for all of us.

I appreciate my family and friends, especially Ellen, for standing by me throughout this ordeal. They prayed with me and for me, and assured me that they believed in me. I thank my classmates from Achimota and Presec, who remained supportive and loyal to me in all those years, always telling me “Don’t mind them; they are just jealous”. There were a few people at Legon that had the courage to openly defend me and were not afraid to be seen with me. They know themselves, and I thank them for doing what they could.

The court awarded GHS 300,000 as damages, including aggravated damages, to me. I thank the court for that and I intend to donate the entirety of the award to charity.

I wish Professor Ebenezer Oduro Owusu well. I also pray that people who assume any office in Ghana in future will not see it as an opportunity to harass or persecute their supposed or perceived enemies. I never saw myself as an enemy or opponent of my successor. I still do not understand what I did to deserve what I have been put through. May be, one day ………..

Ernest Aryeetey

Former Vice Chancellor, University of Ghana (2010-2016)

22 COMMENTS

  1. Indeed, a good name is better than riches. Posterity will remember your good name Prof. It takes bravery to defend oneself, when all odds are against you!

  2. As a student at UG during your reigns as Vice Chancellor, I saw massive developments and growth of the university. We, as students appreciated your sense of drive and innovation. I was never in doubt that your successor was on a maddening hyper witch hunt. His prime interest was to blackmail and tarnish your diamond glittering reputation. But in the end, you deservingly laughed last.

    Your grandchildren can only redeem their faith in you as an honest statesman – I’m not sure they ever staggered your integrity.

    The question is, what would your successor’s grandchildren think of him? As well as I know, that would be his own cup of tea.

  3. Congratulations Prof. Aryeetey. You’ve always been a courageous man of integrity. I was SRC President in Legon in 1987/’88 academic year and just about two weeks of handing over, I resigned on a matter of principle!! A few of my classmates mocked me but my observation is that the greater majority held me and still hold me in high esteem. Thankfully, I have always admired you from a distance and I am very delighted you have successfully defended yourself and good name!! God bless you Sir. I am extremely delighted…

  4. From the first day I heard this news, I told my wife it is a false story because of the man in question. I know prof personally from his ISEER days, gave the institution IT support and became close to him and his family. l know what he stands for and he thank God the truth is out.

  5. Hmmm UG as an institution is fraught with many issues. The are political groups, ethnic groups, religious groups and various other groups working actively against each other and each trying to crush the other with the least opportunity. Even within departments you come across lecturers who are subtly hostile towards each other. I knew right right from the beginning that the new VC wanted to show the former that I am now in charge and will show you where power lied. Sad but that’s the reality in most of our public universities. Even chairs have to be changed in some departments when a new head is appointed

  6. That’s Prof. Ernest Aryeetey, one of the best VCs Legon has had. We thank God for this victory but it’s a victory within the same family so less jubilation.

  7. Hmmmmm. This animal call human is truly complex. Can we ever work together in love as one. So painful to give off your best to an institution and have enemies develop from within ready to eat you up. Now this… cost to be paid, apologies to be rendered before all these people and in all these media platforms. Could all these be avoided? LOVE FOR ALL Hatred for none.

    Let love prevail. Successors must appreciate their Predecessors and work with them but not try destroy them

  8. That certainly is the character of the Blackman. Instead of meeting your predecessor to discuss how he went in with the project and take his input on the way forward your intent was to make him unpopular. Hmmm, Prof, God bless you for your selfless dedication to the University.

  9. Happy to know the respected VC has been vindicated. Good shall always prevail over evil! Prof., your good works at Legon are visible, till date, for all to see. You have paid your dues. God bless you.

  10. When corrupt people put others like them into office, their intentions are clear. Make him dirty so that when you are dirty people won’t notice. But God has always shown himself able to deliver the poor fellow.

    You still stands out in the crowd Prof.

  11. Your successor displayed grave jealousy of your good self. Because he was of no good, politically motivated, a pliant tool for this inept government to change the name of my university of Ghana to a so called JB Danquah university. Village, unexposed and local professors, shame to them!

  12. He is the only person that was able to reduce overcrowding problems in the Hall and also complete a lot of projects. Ghana should make him president for just a year and he will cause a massive change.

  13. Prof. Aryeetey has done very well for Legon. We saw real and tangible progress at the University during his tenure.
    I really wonder what the bad blood may be between him and Prof. Oduro that would have led to this far. Why hasn’t the successor sought audience with him rather than the public pronouncements? The cost of such public pronouncements from the successor may not have affected just Prof. Aryeetey but the University as a whole.
    Prof. Aryeetey, thanks for all you did for the University of Ghana. Your vision and effort towards building a world-class research-intensive institution are visible for all to see. God bless you!!!

  14. Congratulations to Prof Ernest Aryetey. A Vice-Chancellor whose tenure of office(2010-2016) saw unprecedented massive infrastructure development and building of a world-class research intensive university. A Vice-Chancellor I so much admired and respected during my working life the University of Ghana. Legon.

  15. Am very happy justice was served at the end of the day. Its not the wish of any employee or former employee to engage in legal battle with a former work colleague or employer. But its very difficult to sit down and watch your integrity, character and personality being defamed and called into disrepute. It’s really hard to sit lukewarm whiles you’re being publicly embarrassed, humiliated and falsely accused for no justice cause whiles you know you’re very innocent of all the charges being publicly levelled against you. Sometimes, you have to defy all odds, call the bluff of your detractors and prosecutors and defend your right and integrity. Sometimes, no action can also be falsely interpreted as guilty. For me, am very happy justice has been served and would also serve as warning to those who take interest in defaming other for no justifiable cause except for political interest.

  16. Prof. You’re one of the very few visionary leaders I have witnessed growing up.

    Posterity will always be our judge 🙌🏻🙏

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related articles